The Torcivia v Suffolk County Case: What You Need to Know

If you are a resident of Suffolk County, New York, then you may have heard of the Torcivia v Suffolk County case. In this landmark case, Robert Torcivia sued the county over a property tax issue that eventually made its way up to the Supreme Court of New York. But what exactly happened, and why is it so important?

To understand the significance of this case, we need to delve deeper into the history of Suffolk County and its legal system. Did you know that the county has two separate court systems – the District Court and the Supreme Court? And that Riverhead, NY, is home to the District Court? If you’ve ever wondered how to look up court cases in Suffolk County or who the judge of the Surrogate Court is, then this blog post is for you.

But let’s get back to the Torcivia case. It all started when Robert Torcivia, a resident of the town of Brookhaven, discovered that he had been overcharged on his property taxes for several years. He decided to take legal action against the county, claiming that they had violated his rights under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

The case eventually made its way up to the Supreme Court of New York, where it was heard by Judge Peter Mayer. The court ruled in favor of Torcivia, ordering the county to pay him back the excess taxes that he had paid. This decision set a precedent for future cases involving property tax issues in Suffolk County.

So why is the Torcivia case so important? It serves as a reminder of the importance of individual rights and the ability to seek justice through the legal system. It also highlights the complexities of the legal system in Suffolk County and the need for transparency and accessibility for all residents. In this blog post, we’ll explore the details of the Torcivia case and what it means for the county as a whole. So stay tuned!

Suffolk County Clerk

If you need to obtain public records or legal documents in Suffolk County, New York, you will likely need to go through the Suffolk County Clerk. Here are some important things to keep in mind about the Suffolk County Clerk’s office:

Location and Contact Information

The Suffolk County Clerk’s office is located at the Cohalan Court Complex in Central Islip, New York. You can contact them by phone, fax, mail, or email.

Services Offered

The Suffolk County Clerk’s office provides a wide range of services, including:

  • Filing and recording of legal documents
  • Indexing and maintaining land and court records
  • Issuing marriage licenses
  • Providing access to public records
  • Notarizing documents


Some of the services provided by the Suffolk County Clerk’s office require a fee, while others are free of charge. It’s essential to check their website or contact the Clerk’s office directly to find out the current fee schedule.

Online Services

The Suffolk County Clerk’s office has an online portal that allows residents to access certain documents and records from the comfort of their homes. You may also be able to file some documents and requests online, depending on the type of service you require.

Contacting the Clerk’s Office

If you need assistance or have any questions about the services offered by the Suffolk County Clerk’s office, you can contact them during their regular business hours or look for answers on their official website.

In summary, the Suffolk County Clerk’s office is an essential resource for anyone who needs to access legal documents or public records in Suffolk County, New York. Whether you need to file a legal document or obtain a marriage license, the Clerk’s office can help you navigate the process and ensure you have the necessary paperwork and information.

Torcivia v. Suffolk County New York

In the case of Torcivia v. Suffolk County, a lengthy dispute over an allegedly wrongful death began. Here are some quick facts relating to the case in question:

  • The case began in 2010 when Anthony Torcivia’s son died in custody in a Suffolk County jail.
  • Torcivia filed a lawsuit against the county, alleging the jail’s lack of medical care caused his son’s death.
  • After years of appeals, the case was finally settled in 2021 for $1.4 million.
  • This settlement represents a significant victory for Torcivia and his family, but the case sheds light on a larger issue: the inadequate healthcare provided to inmates in many American jails and prisons.

While the Torcivia case represents a win for a grieving family, it’s important to remember that it’s just one example of many instances in which prisoners have suffered due to inadequate healthcare. In the next section, we’ll take a closer look at this issue and some possible solutions.

Inadequate Healthcare for Inmates

Inmates in jails and prisons across the country are often denied the basic medical care they need to stay healthy. Some of the major issues associated with this problem include:

  • Overcrowding in jails and prisons, which makes it difficult for medical staff to provide adequate care to all inmates.
  • A lack of funding for medical resources, including equipment, staff, and medications.
  • A culture within some jails and prisons that treats inmates as unworthy of proper medical care.

Without proper healthcare, prisoners’ health can quickly deteriorate, leading to unnecessary suffering and even death. In the next section, we’ll look at some possible solutions to this issue.

Possible Solutions

While the issue of inadequate healthcare in jails and prisons is a complicated one, there are some potential solutions that could help improve the situation. Some ideas to consider include:

  • Allocating more funds for medical resources in jails and prisons.
  • Providing better training for medical staff working in these facilities.
  • Encouraging greater oversight and accountability for medical care in prisons and jails.
  • Implementing reforms that reduce overcrowding and make it easier for medical staff to provide care to all prisoners.

By taking steps like these, we can start to improve the health and wellbeing of inmates in jails and prisons across the country.

The Torcivia v. Suffolk County case highlights a critical issue in America’s criminal justice system: the inadequate healthcare provided to many inmates in jails and prisons. By addressing this problem head-on and implementing solutions that prioritize inmates’ health, we can take meaningful steps toward creating a more just and humane criminal justice system.

What District Court is Riverhead NY

Riverhead, NY, located on Long Island, is home to the Suffolk County District Court. This court serves as a lower court that hears and decides criminal and civil cases involving misdemeanors and lesser offenses.


The Suffolk County District Court in Riverhead is located at 3105 Route 112 Building C, in the town of Medford, just south of the Long Island Expressway.

Court Jurisdiction

The Suffolk County District Court in Riverhead has jurisdiction over the townships in Suffolk County, including East Hampton, Southampton, Southold, Riverhead, Shelter Island, and Brookhaven.

Types of Cases

The district court in Riverhead handles a variety of cases, including:

  • Traffic violations and infractions
  • Small claims court cases
  • Civil cases involving amounts up to $15,000
  • Misdemeanor criminal cases
  • Felony preliminary hearings

Court Schedule

The court’s schedule varies depending on the case type and availability of judges, but generally, the Suffolk County District Court in Riverhead is open from Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. It’s best to check the court’s website or call for specific scheduling information.

Parking and Transportation

There is ample parking available at the Suffolk County District Court in Riverhead. For those using public transportation, there are bus routes that serve the area, and the Ronkonkoma Long Island Rail Road station is about a 15-minute drive away.

In conclusion, the Suffolk County District Court in Riverhead is the primary court serving several townships in Suffolk County. It handles a variety of cases, ranging from traffic violations to misdemeanors and small claims. Whether you’re a first-time visitor to the court or a seasoned legal professional, knowing what to expect when you visit can help ease any anxiety or confusion.

Suffolk County Supreme Court Case Search

Finding information about a court case can be vital in many situations. You may need to know past convictions or open cases for research purposes. Searching for court cases in Suffolk County is easy with these steps:

Step 1: Visit the Suffolk County Supreme Court Website

To begin your search, you need to visit the Suffolk County Supreme Court website. Once on the site, you can access the search feature.

Step 2: Access the Case Lookup Feature

From the main menu, click on the “Case Lookup” feature. This will take you to a page where you can run a search on all cases in Suffolk County.

Step 3: Enter the Case Details

Enter specific case details, such as the case number, the name of the defendant, or the name of the plaintiff, into the search bar. The search feature will provide you with a list of cases that match your query.

Step 4: Review the Search Results

After entering the details, the search engine will display a list of cases that match your query. Click on the case number to access more information about the case.

Step 5: Get More Information About the Case

Once you click on a case number, you can view all relevant information about the case, including brief details of charges and court dates.


By utilizing the Suffolk County Supreme Court website’s easy-to-use search feature, anyone can access information about past or current court cases. With the right search criteria, you can quickly and easily find the information you need, making Suffolk County Supreme Court Case Search a must-have tool for anyone seeking information on court cases in Suffolk County.

How to Find Court Cases in Suffolk County NY

If you live in Suffolk County NY and need to find court cases, you’ve come to the right place! Here’s a quick guide on how to look up court cases in Suffolk County NY.

Suffolk County Clerk’s Office

The best place to start looking up court cases is the Suffolk County Clerk’s Office. You can find it at 310 Center Drive, Riverhead, NY 11901. The Clerk’s Office has a website that you can access from anywhere and find records online.

Online Court Records

Suffolk County provides access to online court records through their eCourts system. This allows you to search for court cases using different criteria like case type, plaintiff, defendant, or case number.

New York State Unified Court System

Another way to find court cases in Suffolk County NY is through the New York State Unified Court System. You can access it online or in person at a courthouse near you. The website provides information on how to search for records, court fees, and other information related to the Court.

Public Access Terminals

If you prefer to search for court cases in person, you can head over to any courthouse located in Suffolk County. They provide public access terminals, which allow you to search court cases without needing special permission or clearance. You would only have to pay a nominal fee in case you want to print any document.

Knowing how to search for court cases in Suffolk County NY can be essential when trying to find court records. It’s beneficial to learn how to find these records quickly and efficiently, which can help you save time and money. Hopefully, this guide has been of help.

Who is the Judge of the Surrogate Court in Suffolk County

If you’re involved in a legal matter involving wills or estates in Suffolk County, you may find yourself in the Surrogate Court. But who is the judge overseeing the court proceedings?

Meet Judge Theresa Whelan

The Judge of the Surrogate Court in Suffolk County is the Honorable Theresa Whelan. She was elected to the position in 2015 and presides over various legal matters, including:

  • Probate of Wills
  • Administration Proceedings
  • Estate Litigation
  • Guardianships
  • Adoptions

Education and Career

Judge Whelan received her Juris Doctor degree from St. John’s University School of Law and was admitted to the New York State Bar in 1986. Prior to her election as Surrogate Judge, she served as a Supreme Court Justice and was the first woman elected to the position in Suffolk County.

Responsibilities of the Surrogate Court Judge

Judge Whelan’s role as the Surrogate Court Judge involves interpreting and enforcing the New York State laws related to wills, trusts, and estates. Her responsibilities include:

  • Reviewing and administering wills and trusts
  • Appointing guardians and fiduciaries
  • Reviewing and approving accountings
  • Deciding disputes related to estates

Now that you know who the Surrogate Court Judge is in Suffolk County, you can approach your legal matter with confidence. With Judge Whelan presiding over your case, you can trust that fair and just decisions will be made.

You May Also Like