Disadvantages of Gas Water Heater

Are you considering installing a gas water heater in your home? While gas water heaters have their benefits, it’s important to consider their disadvantages as well. In this blog post, we’ll explore the drawbacks of gas water heaters and compare them to their electric counterparts. From the need for electricity to run to the potential monthly cost difference, we’ll cover all the important factors to help you make an informed decision. So, let’s dive in and discover the pros and cons of gas water heaters!

disadvantages of gas water heater

Disadvantages of Gas Water Heater

Not So Hot: Inconsistent Temperature Control

One of the downsides of owning a gas water heater is the inconsistent temperature control it provides. Unlike its electrical counterpart, gas water heaters tend to fluctuate in terms of water temperature. One minute you’ll be enjoying a nice warm shower, and the next minute you’ll be scalded by piping hot water. It can certainly keep you on your toes, but it’s not the most pleasant experience, especially during the chilly winter months.

Ignite the Hurdles: Installation Challenges

Another drawback of gas water heaters is the installation process. While they may be more cost-effective in the long run, they require a professional to install and connect to a gas line. This means you’ll have to spend extra money on installation fees and possibly even on remodeling your space to accommodate the gas line. It’s like inviting a party planner to your house just to set up a bonfire. Not exactly convenient, is it?

Money Goes Up in Flames: Higher Operating Costs

Gas water heaters may be more energy-efficient than their electric counterparts, but that doesn’t mean they won’t burn a hole in your pocket. Gas prices can fluctuate and increase, which means your monthly operating costs for a gas water heater can vary greatly. It’s like trying to budget for a rollercoaster ride without knowing when the steep drops will come. It can be quite the financial rollercoaster.

Safety First (and Last): Potential Carbon Monoxide Risk

While gas water heaters are generally safe when installed properly, there is a risk of carbon monoxide leakage. Carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless gas that can be harmful or even deadly in high concentrations. So, you’ll need to make sure your gas water heater is well-maintained and regularly inspected to avoid the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning. It’s like having a backyard barbecue with a mysterious gas leak. No one wants to be the main course.

Maintenance Matters: Regular Upkeep Required

Gas water heaters require regular maintenance to keep them running smoothly. This includes cleaning the burner and ensuring proper ventilation. Neglecting maintenance can lead to decreased efficiency and potentially costly repairs. It’s like owning a high-maintenance pet that demands attention and care, except this one doesn’t cuddle or wag its tail.

In conclusion, while gas water heaters have their benefits, such as faster heating and lower energy costs, they also come with several disadvantages. These include inconsistent temperature control, installation challenges, higher operating costs, potential carbon monoxide risk, and regular maintenance requirements. So, before jumping on the gas water heater bandwagon, consider these drawbacks and determine if they align with your needs and preferences. After all, a warm shower is great, but not at the cost of safety and convenience.

Disadvantages of Electric Water Heater

Limited Options for Temperature Control

One of the downsides of using an electric water heater is the limited options for temperature control. Unlike gas water heaters, which allow for precise adjustments, electric models often come with predetermined temperature settings. So, if you prefer your showers on the hotter side or need to lower the temperature for safety reasons, you might find yourself a little disappointed with the lack of flexibility.

Longer Heat-Up Time

If you’re in a hurry and need hot water ASAP, an electric water heater might not be your best bet. Compared to their gas counterparts, electric heaters typically have a longer heat-up time. This means you’ll need to wait a little longer before you can jump in the shower or start washing those dishes. So, if patience isn’t your strong suit, you might want to consider alternatives.

Increased Energy Consumption

Electricity isn’t exactly known for being the most efficient way to heat water. Compared to gas water heaters, which use natural gas as a fuel source, electric heaters tend to consume more energy. This means you could see an increase in your energy bills when using an electric water heater. If you’re looking to keep your utility costs down, you might want to explore other options that are more energy-efficient.

Greater Expense in the Long Run

Speaking of costs, electric water heaters can also be pricier in the long run. While they may have a lower upfront cost compared to gas models, the higher energy consumption can add up over time. So, even if you save a few bucks at the beginning, you might end up spending more in the form of higher energy bills. It’s crucial to consider the overall cost-effectiveness before making your decision.

Dependency on Electricity

Lastly, electric water heaters are entirely dependent on electricity. If there’s a power outage in your area, you’ll be left with no hot water until the electricity is restored. This can be particularly frustrating during emergencies or natural disasters. So, if you live in an area prone to blackouts or want the assurance of hot water even during outages, a gas water heater might be a more reliable choice.

In conclusion, while electric water heaters have their benefits, like lower upfront costs and ease of installation, they also come with a few drawbacks. Limited temperature control, longer heat-up times, increased energy consumption, higher long-term costs, and dependency on electricity are factors worth considering. Ultimately, the decision between gas and electric water heaters will depend on your specific needs, preferences, and the availability of resources in your area.

Does a Gas Water Heater Need Electricity

If you’re considering getting a gas water heater, you may be wondering whether it requires electricity to function. Well, let me enlighten you on this little secret of the plumbing world. Sit tight, because things are about to get shockingly electrifying! cue dramatic music

The Power of Gas

disadvantages of gas water heater

Now, you might think that gas water heaters solely rely on good ol’ natural gas to work their magic. And you wouldn’t be wrong. But hold on to your socks, because electricity does play a role here. It’s like a sneaky sidekick, providing the power for specific parts of the heater’s operation.

Meet the Igniter

Every hero needs an accomplice, and the igniter is the unsung hero of your gas water heater. Responsible for igniting the gas burner, it uses a spark to create a flame that ultimately heats your water. And guess what? It needs electricity to create that spark! So, in a way, an electric spark is the key that turns on the fiery passion of your gas water heater.

Say Hello to the Thermocouple

Now, let’s talk about the thermocouple, another essential player in this water heating symphony. Its job is to detect whether the pilot light of the burner is lit or not. If the pilot light goes out for some reason, the thermocouple sends a signal to the gas valve, telling it to stop the gas flow. How does the thermocouple work, you ask? Well, it harnesses the power of temperature difference to generate electricity. So, in a way, it’s like a tiny, heat-powered electric generator.

The Power Play

Now that you know the electrifying truth about gas water heaters, you might be wondering, “What happens if there’s a power outage?” Fear not, my friend, for there’s a backup plan in place. Most gas water heaters have a safety feature called a standing pilot light. This means that even if the electricity goes out, the pilot light will remain lit, keeping your water heater ready for action.

So, to answer your question, yes, a gas water heater does need electricity, albeit in small doses. It’s like a well-choreographed dance between gas and electricity, with each playing a crucial role in keeping your water warm and toasty. And now you can impress your friends with your newfound plumbing knowledge. Happy heating!

Gas vs Electric Water Heater Monthly Cost

An Honest Look at the Price Tag

When it comes to heating your water, you can go the traditional route with a gas water heater or embrace the modern electricity-powered wonders of an electric water heater. But let’s talk numbers for a moment. Which one will leave your wallet feeling a little too light? Let’s dive into the monthly costs of each and find out!

The Gas Water Heater: Devil without a Flame

So, you’ve chosen the gas water heater cue dramatic music. Sure, it’s reliable, powerful, and gives you that rustic feeling of having a flame right in your basement, but what about the monthly costs?

Well, unfortunately, gas water heaters are known to consume gas with the same vigor as a hungry T-Rex chasing its next meal. They can be quite a burden on your wallet, as gas prices can fluctuate like a roller coaster ride that never seems to end. It’s like throwing your hard-earned money into a volcano and hoping for a warm shower in return.

Electric Water Heater: Lights, Camera, No Action

On the other hand, we have the electric water heater, the sleek and modern option that promises to keep your showers warm without the hassle of burning gas. But is it really as cost-effective as we’re led to believe?

Let’s face it, electricity bills are like those clingy friends who always seem to pop up at the worst times. And when you add an electric water heater into the mix, those bills can skyrocket faster than a superhero on caffeine. Plus, if you live in an area with high electricity rates, you might just end up performing a little juggling act with your budget to keep those warm showers going.

The Winner Is…

Well, there’s no clear winner in this battle of the water heaters. It ultimately depends on your personal situation, energy rates, and your love for T-Rex costumes (just kidding, but feel free to rock it if you want to).

So, take a moment to analyze your wallet, check the current gas and electricity rates in your area, and decide which water heater will be your trusty companion. And hey, if you’re feeling extra adventurous, you could always go for a solar water heater and rely on the good ol’ sun to warm your showers. Just make sure to keep your shades on!

When it comes to monthly costs, the gas vs. electric water heater debate can be a tricky one. While gas water heaters may eat up your budget faster than a kid devours candy, electric water heaters can shock you with their high electricity bills. Ultimately, your decision should be based on factors such as local energy rates, personal preferences, and the alignment of the stars (just kidding about the stars). So, choose wisely, and may your showers be warm and your budget intact!

Disadvantages of Tankless Gas Water Heaters

While tankless gas water heaters are often praised for their energy efficiency and endless hot water supply, there are a few drawbacks to consider. Let’s take a lighthearted look at some of the disadvantages you might encounter when opting for a tankless gas water heater.

1. Cold Showers Surprise Party

Picture this: you’re in the middle of a warm, relaxing shower when suddenly the water turns ice-cold. A delightful surprise, indeed! With a tankless gas water heater, there can be a slight delay between when you turn on the hot water and when it actually starts flowing. So, be prepared for a spontaneous “cold showers only” party every now and then.

2. The Waiting Game

Have you ever found yourself impatiently tapping your foot while waiting for the hot water to reach your faucet? Well, with a tankless gas water heater, you might become a little too familiar with this waiting game. Unlike traditional water heaters that store hot water in a tank, tankless models take a bit longer to heat up the water. So, if you’re someone who values instant gratification, this might put your patience to the test.

3. The Price Tag Tango

Tankless gas water heaters are undeniably more expensive upfront compared to their tank-style counterparts. So, if you’re on a tight budget, you might find yourself doing the “price tag tango” to figure out if the long-term savings on energy bills will make up for the initial investment. It’s a dance of dollars and cents!

4. Limited Output Orchestra

While tankless gas water heaters can provide endless hot water, there is a limitation to their output. If you have a large household with multiple people using hot water simultaneously, the tankless system might struggle to keep up with the demand, and you might find yourself in a bit of a hot water shortage. In such cases, compromising on your daily karaoke sessions in the shower might be necessary.

5. The Guilty Eco-Consciousness

Yes, tankless gas water heaters are more energy-efficient, but they do have a continuous pilot light that needs to stay lit. So, although they’re eco-friendly in terms of heating water efficiently, they still contribute to a carbon footprint. It’s like enjoying the benefits of energy efficiency while having a tiny guilt monster sitting on your shoulder.

While tankless gas water heaters have their advantages, such as saving space and reducing energy wastage, it’s essential to consider the potential downsides. If you’re someone who loves immediate hot water, hates waiting, or has a household full of hot water enthusiasts, these drawbacks might require some thoughtful consideration. It’s all about finding the perfect balance between convenience, cost, and long-term benefits for your unique needs.

Should I Replace My Electric Water Heater with a Gas Water Heater

So, you’re thinking about making the switch from an electric water heater to a gas water heater, eh? Well, let’s dive into the pros and cons of such a decision. Grab your funny bone and let’s weigh the options!

Electric water heater, you’ve been great…but is it time to move on

Gas, gas, gas… and I don’t mean the kind you put in your car!

1. Efficiency – or lack thereof

Let’s be real here. Electric water heaters have a bad rap when it comes to efficiency. They tend to gobble up those kilowatts quicker than a kid with a candy stash. On the other hand, gas water heaters are known for their energy efficiency. So, if you’re looking to save some dollars on your utility bill, gas might just be the way to go.

2. Speedy showers and raging rivers

Picture this: you’ve had a long, exhausting day and all you want is a hot, soothing shower. Cue the dramatic music Unfortunately, electric water heaters are notorious for their slower recovery time. Those electric coils need time to heat up, and ain’t nobody got time for that! With gas water heaters, you’ll enjoy faster recovery time, meaning you won’t have to wait ages for that oh-so-heavenly hot shower.

3. It’s time to break up…with your beloved dryer

If you’re considering switching to a gas water heater, here’s a friendly reminder: you might have to say goodbye to that electric dryer you love so much. Gas water heaters require a gas line, which means running one to your water heater location. If your electric water heater is already situated in a convenient spot, this might not be an issue. But if you’re looking to move things around, be prepared for some additional work.

4. Safety first, folks

Here’s the thing. Gas water heaters bring the potential for gas leaks and carbon monoxide issues. Yikes! While it’s rare, it’s still a legitimate concern. Electric water heaters, on the other hand, don’t pose the same safety risks. So, if peace of mind is high on your priority list, you might want to think twice about that gas water heater.

Final Thoughts: The verdict is yours!

Replacing your electric water heater with a gas water heater has its perks, like increased efficiency and faster recovery time. However, it also brings potential safety concerns and might require additional work if you need to run a gas line. So, before making the switch, weigh the advantages and disadvantages to see what fits your needs best. After all, a warm and toasty shower should be a delightful experience, not a nightmare!

disadvantages of gas water heater

Which is Better: Gas or Electric Hot Water Heater


When it comes to choosing between a gas or electric hot water heater, it can be a heated debate (pun intended). Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, but today we’re going to focus on the disadvantages of gas water heaters. So, grab your favorite hot beverage and let’s dive in!

Initial Cost: Gas Water Heater

If you’re looking to save some cash upfront, a gas water heater might not be your best bet. These bad boys can be quite expensive to purchase and install. You’ll need to invest in a gas line if you don’t already have one, and that can add to the cost. Consider it your own personal “money pit!”

Energy Efficiency: Electric Water Heater

If being eco-friendly is a priority for you, an electric water heater may give you a warm, fuzzy feeling inside. They tend to be more energy efficient compared to their gas counterparts. So not only can you save the environment, but you can also save some moolah on your monthly energy bills. It’s a win-win!

disadvantages of gas water heater

Limited Hot Water Supply: Gas Water Heater

Picture this: you get home from a long day, dreaming of a relaxing hot shower, only to find out that your gas water heater has betrayed you! One of the downsides of gas water heaters is that they have a limited hot water supply. So if you’re the type who enjoys marathon showers or you have a big family, be prepared for some potential cold water surprises.

Lifespan: Electric Water Heater

They say good things come to those who wait, and that’s certainly the case with electric water heaters. These babies have a longer lifespan compared to gas water heaters. So if you’re in it for the long haul and don’t want to deal with the hassle of replacing your water heater anytime soon, electric is the way to go!

Maintenance and Safety: Gas Water Heater

Maintenance and safety are two important aspects to consider, especially when it comes to something as vital as a water heater. Gas water heaters require more frequent maintenance compared to their electric counterparts. And let’s not forget the ever-present danger of gas leaks! You’ll want to make sure you have a carbon monoxide detector handy and perform regular maintenance to prevent any unwelcome surprises.

In the battle of gas vs electric hot water heaters, both sides have their pros and cons. Gas water heaters can be costly upfront, have a limited hot water supply, and require more maintenance. On the other hand, electric water heaters are more energy efficient, have a longer lifespan, and don’t come with the same safety concerns. Ultimately, the choice comes down to your individual needs and preferences. So, take some time and weigh your options before deciding which type of water heater will keep you comfortably warm.

Pros and Cons of Gas Water Heater


1. Cost-Effective Heating

Gas water heaters are known for their cost-effective heating compared to electric models. With gas being a more affordable energy source than electricity, you can save quite a bit on your monthly utility bills.

2. Quick Recovery Time

One of the benefits of a gas water heater is its quick recovery time. When you run out of hot water, you won’t have to wait too long for the water heater to heat up a fresh supply. So those long, cold showers can be a thing of the past!

3. Reliable Performance

Gas water heaters are known for their reliable performance. They are built to withstand heavy usage and can provide hot water consistently. So you can rely on your gas water heater to meet your demands, whether it’s for multiple showers a day or running multiple appliances at once.

4. Better for the Environment

If you’re conscious about reducing your carbon footprint, a gas water heater is a better option compared to electric models. Gas produces fewer greenhouse gas emissions during the heating process, making it a more environmentally-friendly choice.


1. Limited Installation Options

One downside of gas water heaters is their limited installation options. They require a gas line, which may not be available in all areas or require additional setup costs. So if you don’t already have a gas line in your home, it could be an added expense to consider.

2. Potential Safety Risks

Gas water heaters come with their own set of safety considerations. If not properly maintained or installed, gas leaks or carbon monoxide leaks can pose a serious risk. It’s important to have your gas water heater regularly inspected by a professional to ensure safe operation.

3. Higher Upfront Cost

Compared to electric water heaters, gas water heaters generally have a higher upfront cost. From the initial purchase to installation, the expenses can add up. However, the long-term energy savings and performance often outweigh this initial investment.

4. Noise Level

Gas water heaters can be noisy during operation, especially when the burner ignites to heat the water. The noise may not be too bothersome for some, but if you’re sensitive to sounds or have the water heater located near living areas, it’s something worth considering.

In conclusion, gas water heaters offer cost-effective heating, quick recovery time, and reliable performance. They are also better for the environment compared to electric models. However, there are some limitations, including limited installation options, potential safety risks, higher upfront costs, and noise levels to consider. So weigh these pros and cons before deciding if a gas water heater is the right choice for your home.

Is it Cheaper to Have a Gas or Electric Water Heater

When it comes to choosing between a gas water heater and an electric water heater, cost is a significant factor to consider. Let’s take a closer look at the burning question: Is it cheaper to have a gas or electric water heater? Get ready to break out the calculator!

Initial Installation Cost

When comparing the initial installation costs, gas water heaters tend to be more expensive than their electric counterparts. You’ll need to factor in the cost of special ventilation requirements for gas heaters, which can add to the overall expense. On the other hand, electric water heaters usually don’t require any additional ventilation, making them a bit easier on the wallet.

Operational Cost

Now here’s where things get interesting. While gas water heaters may have a higher upfront cost, they tend to be more energy-efficient and can lead to lower monthly utility bills. Gas is generally cheaper than electricity, so heating water using gas can be more cost-effective in the long run, especially if you use a significant amount of hot water.

Regional Factors

It’s important to consider your location when deciding between a gas or electric water heater. Gas prices can vary depending on your region, so it’s crucial to research and compare gas and electricity costs in your area. If you happen to live in a region where electricity is relatively cheaper than gas, an electric water heater might be a more cost-efficient option for you.

Other Considerations

When contemplating the cost of your water heater, it’s wise to take a holistic approach. Gas water heaters generally have a longer lifespan compared to electric ones. So while the initial installation might be pricier, you may end up saving money in the long term by avoiding replacement costs. Additionally, gas water heaters can still provide hot water during a power outage, whereas an electric water heater would be rendered useless without electricity.

The Verdict

In conclusion, determining whether it is cheaper to have a gas or electric water heater depends on various factors such as initial installation cost, operational cost, regional pricing, and other considerations. While gas water heaters may have a higher upfront expense, they offer potential savings in terms of monthly bills and can weather power outages. Ultimately, it’s crucial to consider your specific circumstances and evaluate the available options to make an informed decision that suits your budget and needs. So, crunch the numbers with diligence, and may your hot showers be both soothing and cost-effective!

You May Also Like